The Pitch is a reality series about advertising agencies competing against each other for new business. The draw is that we consumers all want a glimpse into the real happenings behind the ads we see. It begins with two firms pitching ideas to Subway executives.
SPOILER ALERT: this post discusses AMC's The Pitch season 1, episode 1.
The two competitors, while both fierce and hungry, immediately come across as different in how they operate and approach winning the business.
Right out of the gate Tracy Wong, Founding Partner, WDCW in Los Angeles, makes it clear how this world isn’t kind to advertising agencies by explaining that “You start clawing, scratching, swimming – that’s what you do.”
The stage is set by Wong leaving a generic motel room. Ah, the joy of business travel, I recognize that.
Next we have the pleasure of meeting the competition. In a rented van, we meet Liz Paradise, Creative Director, McKinney Advertising in North Carolina. “Here we are” Liz says in a singsong voice along with a friendly smile that is sharp as a razor’s edge. A piece of business is up for grabs and she’s in it to win it. Liz explains “Every ad agency in America wants to be invited to that process, to win that piece of business. We are competitive.” The desire to be the winning team is clearly huge, especially coming from her dead-on serious face.
The process begins with a briefing for the two agencies at Subway’s Headquarters in Milford, CT. We hear things like, “Here they come. Well, this won’t be too awkward” from McKinney. Wired Wong (nicknamed with love for his ferocious passion) shares, “Shoot, how are you going win an account? You gotta to slug it out in the gladiator arena with all these other naked, glistening, sword-wielding agencies.” Now that’s a visual I can't get out of my head easily.
The battle starts with modern day posturing. You see handshaking and smiles, but like Eminem said “You only get one shot, do not miss your chance to blow – this opportunity comes once in a lifetime.”
You might think WDCW has an edge because of their work with Quizno’s, but only until Subway’s CMO expresses how completely unimpressed he was with that work. The balloon is burst, but don’t worry, that only makes Wired Wong stronger.
McKinney is a medium-sized agency that exudes a formidable, yet tamed passion, perhaps due to Liz Paradise’s viewpoint that McKinney has a “Southern gentility that has washed into the culture of the agency.” They talk a bit about how people in the south are more accepting, and I couldn’t help but notice, painted on a blood red wall, is what must be a company value: LISTEN, PROVOKE, LOVE, SIMPLIFY, BELIEVE.
Both agencies are ready for the first step, the briefing and Paradise says it best: “When the CMO talks you shut up and listen.”
The Subway team enters the room, led by marketing veteran, Tony Pace, Chief Marketing Officer. Tony details the specific goal: a new assignment for breakfast. The Subway breakfast initiative launched in April 2010 and now they want to take it to the next level by focusing on a single demographic, people 18-24. Tony makes it clear he doesn’t want to see “SOS” (aka “Save on Subway”). The Pitches must include something they’ve never seen before.
Next, each agency brainstorms.
WDCW narrows it down to two ideas. First is Greasy Town. Yep, I just said Greasy Town. It’s about one guy who’s not going to take it anymore. He drives with conviction in his heart that people deserve a better breakfast. Greasy Town? Ick.
The second is a play on Zombies. This concept is all about zAMbies that mimic the walking dead until they get a Subway breakfast Sandwich. Sorry folks, I couldn’t think of a different descriptor than how they were portrayed – which is a take on another AMC show The Walking Dead series. Wonky Wong feels that it’s nonsensical so the zAMbie idea could work.
Over at McKinney, a breakfast matchmaker is kiboshed ASAP, as well as an idea involving a dead body (wow, mornings really are viewed as a time of coming back to life!). We hear other ideas including sandwiches as art and something about cheerleaders until the room is silenced with “Is that all you got?”
Finally, McKinney lands on two strong ideas to bring to Subway. The first idea is tied to a theme of "Let’s Fix Breakfast!" and involves a talk show that depicts a Subway Sandwich as king. The king lords it over cheesy breakfast competitors like energy drinks, bearclaws, and other non-fresh on-the-go breakfast items.
The second idea is Freestyle Breakfast. McKinney finds Mac Lethal, a breakfast rapper with rapidly growing YouTube views. They snap him up, then create a video at a Subway that's a step up from YouTube, and build creative around it.
Both teams are taking huge risks and they know it. WDCW’s zAMbie concept is unlike anything they’ve ever done. It includes a very annoying commercial that hurt my ears. However, their passion for it is so strong it won me over just like the Meatloaf song, I Would Do Anything For Love. Yep, their passion for zAMbie is that powerful.
McKinney loves the Mac Lethal rap, however it creates a conundrum because they must work backwards to create advertising from the rap. There’s some very healthy dialog between McKinney team members. The younger team wants to focus on the rapper and the veteran team reminds them that at the end of the day it must be about the product. This raises a compelling generational viewpoint. A younger McKinney writer makes the excellent point that she doesn’t want the ad to scream "commercial" or force the message. She doesn’t waiver while going head-to-head with someone that could probably get her fired. She holds strong to her viewpoint, and I give her kudos for it.
It’s execution time…
The final 12 hours…the not-so-glamorous business trip begins for both teams as they show up in their Sunday best.
McKinney starts the pitch with “Let’s Fix Breakfast” and “Freestyle Breakfast.”
The Let’s Fix Breakfast idea is described as a talk show hosted by Subway breakfast sandwiches and an audience comprised of Subway breakfast sandwiches.
Subway looks unimpressed. Steely silence fills the room. So McKinney moves on to the second strategy – Mac Lethal. They run the Freestyle video. Smiles breakout amongst the Subway team…there’s even a few chuckles. Heads are nodding up and down. Mac Lethal delivers an impromptu rap in-person and everyone claps – as if it were Glee!
Now WDCW is up and they launch into a description of Breakfast Zombies…now called zAMbies. They display the incredibly bold creative as well as an extremely loud commercial. It caught the attention of Subway execs who smiled and laughed.
Finally, it comes down to decision time.
Subway execs appreciate the robotic creative such as the No Be zAMbie tagline, but raise the question of how it fits with the brand.
The conversation moves to McKinney, who thought they had a strong strategic starting point. Subway felt McKinney understood the challenge and translated it very well with insights into the creative.
But this is no easy decision. Subway can’t ignore that WDCW grasped the 18-24 target language and culture. Subway VP, Suzanne Greco, commented that neither agency delivered on the appetite appeal, making the food look so good that everyone wants to rush into Subway for a breakfast sandwich.
Stomachs are churning with anxiety for both teams, and viewers as we wait for the final decision.
Subway execs come out and share that sometimes it comes down to a narrow margin, however the win goes to McKinney! Immediately, Liz Paradise takes a moment to recognize her team as the backbone of the win – well done Liz.
Tracy Wong stresses that WCDW believes in focusing on form and process. They are an agency that believes in sticking to passion and conviction, not about winning or losing. It’s clear they are a group with cutting-edge ideas.
The show fades with McKinney celebrating a very big win! High fives, cheers, hugs and tears! The joy of teamwork wins the challenge of the Subway breakfast sandwich!
I've been part of new business pitches on both the client and agency side. You're part of pitches, or seeing it around you in your agency.
-
Do you think the show honestly captured the process?
-
Was it more reality or show?
-
Does it have an audience beyond us agency / media geeks?
I'm going to keep watching and decide. Let me know what you think.